'Politics should be about people, not profit'
'Starvation Lake' a tasty mystery
Couple whose baby died of starvation did not commit crime, sources
Agilent Goes Into Starvation Mode
Is 'scapegoating' behind baby's starvation death?
$6M settlement for starved Everett boy
Sands’s Starvation, Boils Dramatized in IRA Film: Rick Warner
Obama must halt starvation in Darfur
VIDEO: Kenya drought - starvation feared
Enough, population doom merchants
Cafeteria strike against Meriwether Godsey causes chaos and starvation
Permanent URL for this page: http://go.worldbank.org/5IWA37WFB0
Contradictions in the World Banks India Country Assistance Strategy
http://www.brettonwoodsproject.org/art-72279
The India Country Assistance Strategy (CAS) identifies the operations the World Bank intends to finance for the period 2005-08 and the rationale for these operations. The CAS is ambitious and comprehensive in its coverage; it intends to significantly influence reform in governance at the central and state level, on macro-economic issues as well as in key sectors such as energy, health, water, education, agriculture and trade as its basis for extending loans. On 7 August 2004, representatives of social movements, national alliances and civil society organisations met in New Delhi and issued a statement explicitly rejecting the Bank's strategy for India.
The Bank invited comments on the CAS for less than a month on its website. This was clearly insufficient for a public consultation as it excluded the vast majority of people and groups in India who do not have access to the internet. Moreover the CAS was incomplete; crucial annexes constituting important policy directives (for e.g. guidelines for lending and the private sector development strategy) were unavailable to the public.
The central thread of the document with respect to the power sector is the key role of privatisation and high investment; evident from the fact that the bulk of the Bank's initiatives are dealt with in the section 'promoting private sector led growth'. It is shocking that the Bank continues advocating privatisation as 'the policy option', when there have been serious demonstrated problems, in the Indian power sector. Limitations of the existing regulatory mechanisms to handle private sector actors and market forces, complexities created by the existing information asymmetry, imbalances in service costs to various classes of consumers, and the limited role and ability of civil society organizations to provide checks and balances to market forces need to be taken into account before privatisation attempts can be furthered.
The Bank's plans to offer investments in hydroelectric generation ignore important lessons from the past. With dam projects such as the Sardar Sarovar in the Narmada valley, infrastructure lending has a contentious history in India but the Bank has consistently refused to accept its responsibility for the unresolved social and environmental legacy of its dam projects. Incredulously the CAS claims that some major actors including the National Hydroelectric Power Corporation (NHPC) have started to "improve their environmental and social safeguards practices". By deciding to work with the NHPC the Bank aids an institution that is notorious for brutal displacement without resettlement, no guidelines for public hearing and poor environmental and social assessment. Violations have been reported from almost all the on-going hydro projects of NHPC - from Jammu and Kashmir to Arunachal Pradesh.
The Bank is appreciative of the recent reduction in average tariffs on agricultural products and advocates for the improvement in the legal framework to enable the easy sale and transfer of lands. The former has already resulted in the dumping of agricultural products, causing a free-fall in farm prices whereas the latter will erode the very livelihood base of India's small-hold and marginal farmers. Considered one of the prime causes of suicides by farmers, it is unimaginable to think of them as solutions to the problems of the agriculture sector. The CAS comes heavily against subsidies in any form and advocates strongly for full recovery of recurring cost of generating and distribution of electricity. Electricity is not just a tradable commodity for farmers. Along with water and farmgate price, it is one the three crucial elements for the sustenance of their occupation.
The Bank also seeks to increase its array of partnerships with local research and academic institutions in both developing its analytical work and disseminating important findings; re-shaped analytical and advisory activities (AAA) will actually promote its reform and private sector-led development paradigm trying to change the country's face of information gathering and dissemination mechanisms. The Bank aims to use its immense financial resources to produce its own version of 'knowledge'. The Bank's strategy here is not to stifle dissent as much as it is to neutralise it... it is more to "normalise" its view of the world and development issues.
The Bank through its reform programmes, knowledge activities and private sector dominated worldview will shape India's policy, economic and social environment. But the extent to which this is possible should be determined by India's democratic institutions. Civil society groups have mounted a campaign calling upon local governments, legislative assemblies and the Indian parliament to reject this document, as it is an affront to the social justice and democratic traditions of the Indian constitution.
Comment by Benny Kuruvilla of Focus on the Global South
We welcome submissions from representatives of Southern civil society organisations for the “comment” feature. If you are interested in contributing please contact comment@brettonwoodsproject.org.
Related resources
- Focus on the Global South Background|Focus on the Global South|21 September 2004|Website|URL
- World Bank India page At Issue|Bretton Woods Project|17 September 2004|-|
Special coverage of the financial crisis, G20 summits, and moves towards a Bretton Woods II conference can now be found on our partner site:
www.rethinkingfinance.orgNewswire
G20 must look beyond the needs of the top 20 27 March
Reform is needed. Reform is in the air. We can't afford to fail 27 March
ICSID tribunal dismisses RSM Production Corporation�s claim against Grenada 26 March
Philippines public sector executives in World Bank mess face raps 26 March
IMF, World Bank still stuck in the past 26 March
Talks on new world reserve currency 'legitimate': IMF chief 26 March
IMF offers new tools for global downturn 25 March
China calls for new global currency 24 March
YouTube - Competitiveness: Creating a Mongolian Economic Strategy
www.youtube.com/watch?v=GCdmrAPT8pk - 133k - Cached - Similar pages -
Sunday, March 22, 2009 HOME | IMAGES | VIDEOS | BLOGS | LIVE CHAT ...
www.mynews.in/fullstory.aspx?storyid=13601 - 141k - Cached - Similar pages -
- The McKinsey Quarterly - business management strategy - Economic ...
www.mckinseyquarterly.com/India_and_China_Asias_non-identical_twins_82 - 193k - Cached - Similar pages -
Strategy Paper To Bring Audio Video-related Services Under Gatt On ...
www.financialexpress.com/news/strategy-paper-to-bring-audio-videorelated-services-under-gatt-on-cards/43232/ - 57k - Cached - Similar pages -
Obama's Strategy For Iran - CBS News Video
www.cbsnews.com/video/watch/?id=4788270n - 61k - Cached - Similar pages -
Video: President Obama to invest $5bn in Pakistan as part of ...
www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/us_and_americas/article5987406.ece - Similar pages -
RPT-Dell eyes Indian small firms, plots sales strategy | Reuters
www.reuters.com/article/technology-media-telco-SP/idUSBOM3036120070712 - 58k - Cached - Similar pages -
Australia: A country in denial - Strategy - Business Management ...
www.builderau.com.au/strategy/businessmanagement/soa/Australia-A-country-in-denial/0,339028271,320283263,00.htm - 56k - Cached - Similar pages -
YouTube LLC's Strategy in India - Micro Case Studies - Marketing ...
www.icmrindia.org/business%20Updates/micro%20casestudies/Marketing/MCMK0032.htm - 14k - Cached - Similar pages -
Did you mean to search for: India Country strategy video
1 |
Policy rebootDaily News & Analysis - 3 hours ago I am announcing a comprehensive, new strategy for Afghanistan and Pakistan" was the opening line of the much awaited Barack Obama speech on Friday. ... Worldview: Signs of hope in Obama's Afghan plan Philadelphia Inquirer India, Iran discuss Afghan situation Press Trust of India Real estate for retail chains reflect blocked funds and inventory ...Economic Times - 15 hours ago Till October 2008 the real estate industry was a very booming industry in India. Also the high net worth of individual investors especially those involved ... Any takers for one man's army?Daily News & Analysis - 20 hours ago As in the virtues of having one prime minister to run a country and one editor a newspaper, I believe cricket (even T20) is best served by one captain. ... Australian Grudge against Ganguly Newstrack India 'Third Front is like a parking lot'Business Standard - 20 hours ago Bharat ko chalana koi bacchon ka khel nahin hai (governing a country like India is no child’s play). The leader has to tackle multi-dimensional problems, ... Camera phones sales up amid slowdownEconomic Times - Mar 28, 2009 "We are currently finalising the go-to-market strategy for this phone which will centre around the photography platform," a Nokia India spokeswoman said. ... JSW Steel: HoldHindu Business Line - 20 hours ago The company plans to open another 50 outlets across the country and have a pan-India presence. The improvement in sales for JSW Steel in the ongoing March ... Brand Advani: Perils Of Rebranding!CounterCurrents.org - 21 hours ago It was late eighties when one was witness to the growing surge of the 'biggest movement in independent India' led by the Sangh Parivar which ultimately ... DLF's retail arm plans 500 luxury lifestyle storesBusiness Standard - Mar 27, 2009 D LF Brands, the retail management subsidiary of DLF, the country’s biggest developer, plans to open 500 stores selling luxury lifestyle labels in the next ... Donna Karan to enter India with DLF Brands Times of India 'Outsourcing will be more widely accepted'Hindu - Mar 27, 2009 Going forward, the strategy for the Indian BPO industry would be to protect India’s cost advantage: to ensure that buyer interest, adoption and growth are ... Testing time for IT Sify Luxury brands got India strategy wrong, says expertEconomic Times - Mar 25, 2009 NEW DELHI: Global luxury brand owners who have set up shop in India to tap the growing affluent class seem to have gone wrong in estimating the break-even ... |
Marchers call on G20 to take action on povertyRadio Netherlands - 21 hours ago ... of the British capital London today, calling on G20 countries to develop a worldwide programme to combat poverty, unemployment and climate change. ... 100000 expected on London global poverty march Glasgow Daily Record In photos: 'Britain G20 Protests' Monsters and Critics.com Declining poverty ups UPA's re-election chances: StudyEconomic Times - Mar 27, 2009 While poverty has declined in 380 of the 543 Lok Sabha constituencies in the past five years, an analysis by the Economic & Political Weekly (EPW) shows ... Africa’s poverty, global crisis have same rootThe Punch - 4 hours ago While other countries manufactured themselves into riches, we remain mired in poverty by consuming what they produce. We want more and more of what we can ... Darling cannot afford to ignore child povertyguardian.co.uk - 15 hours ago This month marks the 10th anniversary of the Labour government's pledge to eradicate child poverty. We have come a long way since, lifting 600000 children ... The rise of 'poortainment'Business Standard - 20 hours ago Moreover, it is not politically correct to just ignore poverty. The solution is to put poverty in a zoo, and sanitise it, even romanticise it. ... Welwyn Hatfield MP criticised for missing fuel poverty voteTimes 24 - 6 hours ago WELWYN Hatfield MP Grant Shapps has been accused of failing to support a crucial bill aimed at stamping out fuel poverty. Lib Dem parliamentary candidate ... Video: Thousands of Families Who Overcame Poverty Reach Out to ...FOXBusiness - Mar 27, 2009 "For more than six decades, Passing on the Gift has been a cornerstone of Heifer's mission to end hunger and fight poverty, and these ceremonies are a ... |
Global water sector challenges are large in scale, diversity and ...The News International - 17 hours ago ... including poverty and hunger eradication, water-related disaster reduction, health, agricultural and rural development, hydropower, food security, ... The Second Shockwave Now Hits Developing WorldThe Epoch Times - Mar 27, 2009 The greatest worry is that most of the gains achieved in eradicating poverty over the last decade or so will be wiped out, forcing tens or hundreds of ... Human Rights Council concludes tenth regular sessionReliefWeb (press release) - 12 hours ago On the right to food, the Council expresses its concern that women and girls are disproportionately affected by hunger, food insecurity and poverty; ... Human Rights Council closes tenth session, extending mandate of ... ReliefWeb (press release) Online Chat Spotlights Most-Ailing Millennium GoalWomen's eNews - 6 hours ago Annie Raja is general secretary of the National Federation of Indian Women, which campaigns for issues such as food security. The target set by MDG 5 is to ... Napep and poverty eradicationFinancial Standard - Mar 17, 2009 Undoubtedly, the Senate is right in advising the Federal Government to reposition the country’s foreign policy focus and make food security the focal point. ... Letters : A time for global actionJakarta Post - Mar 28, 2009 ... food security, universal access to education, public health, human rights and the eradication of extreme poverty, and also suggest remedial actions. ... Brazil, Chile and Caricom countries back FAO's proposal for a ...TV 5 Monde (Communiqué de presse) - Mar 23, 2009 At a meeting with Diouf on 7 March, President Bachelet indicated her support for the proposed World Summit of Heads of State and Government on Food Security ... Do voters have different criteria for choosing candidate for Lk ...Central Chronicle - Mar 28, 2009 The issues may relate to defence of the country, fighting the menace of terrorism, eradication of poverty and fighting corruption at various levels. ... Fight against famine, poverty are government priorities - ministerAngolaPress - Mar 18, 2009 ... and its partners actions towards the eradication of famine and reduction of poverty. The food security strategy considers food as a fundamental right to ... |
Project list - Food Security
www.eudelbangladesh.org/en/projects/foodsecurity_projects.htm - 80k - Cached - Similar pages -
[PDF]
Community-led approaches to ending food insecurity and poverty M S ...
basic approach to poverty eradication has to be asset building and human development. ...... ending food insecurity at the level of each individual. ...
www.ifad.org/poverty/swa.pdf - Similar pages -
by MS Swaminathan - 2000 - Cited by 4 - Related articles
[PDF]
RIS Discussion Papers
of the background note prepared for FAO Regional High-Level Roundtable on Eradication of Poverty and Food Insecurity, 23-24 February 2004, Bangkok. ...
www.ris.org.in/dp87_pap.pdf - Similar pages -
by S Chaturvedi - Related articles - All 3 versions
Agriculture, food security and poverty alleviation | GroundReport
www.groundreport.com/Lifestyle/Agriculture-food-security-and-poverty-alleviation - 41k - Cached - Similar pages -
PODIUM :: Food Security
podium.iwmi.org/podium/FoodSecurity.asp - 26k - Cached - Similar pages -
Local famines, global food insecurity
www.odihpn.org/report.asp?id=2644 - 18k - Cached - Similar pages -
Maddox Jolie-Pitt Foundation Official Website | Agriculture ...
www.mjpasia.org/agriculture.htm - 20k - Cached - Similar pages -
|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Log on to 
No comments:
Post a Comment